Apeks Marine & EngineeringApeks Marine

Regulation & Inspection

Brazilian Court Orders Cruise Ship Buenavista Detained at Santos

A Brazilian court ordered ex-Oriana cruise ship Buenavista detained at Santos in a tour operator dispute; a separate inspection reportedly cited crew and safety deficiencies.

A Troubled Debut for Corazul

A Brazilian judge ordered the cruise ship Buenavista detained at the Port of Santos as of November 13, in a fee dispute between Spanish cruise line Corazul and its Brazilian tour operator, The Maritime Executive reported on November 20. Brazilian authorities separately inspected the ship and, according to reports, cited it for crew and safety deficiencies. Corazul had already suspended sailings weeks after launch.

Meyer Werft built the 69,000-gross-ton vessel. It sailed as P&O Cruises’ Oriana from 1995 to 2019, then operated in China as Astro Ocean’s Piano Land for roughly seven years. Corazul took delivery in September, made a brief shipyard stop in Hong Kong, and renamed the vessel Buenavista for its planned Santos launch.

From Rust Stains to a Court Detention

Buenavista arrived at Santos in late October. Reports attributed rust stains on its hull to the ocean transit from Hong Kong and a lay-up off Hong Kong since June, before Corazul took delivery.

The line began mini-preview cruises for travel-trade members. Two swimming pools were out of service and the casino was closed. Passengers reported malfunctioning plumbing, inconsistent service and apparent crew shortages. After two short voyages, Corazul paused operations for upgrades before the peak season and promised refunds to affected passengers.

Tour operator R11, which held a four-year exclusive distribution agreement with Corazul, sued the line. R11 claimed more than $1.1 million in fees and commissions, while acknowledging that it held $925,000 in passenger receipts under an arrangement in which Corazul is paid only once a cruise departs. The judge ruled for R11 and ordered the ship detained. Corazul must post roughly $300,000 plus costs to secure its release. R11 has 30 days to pursue its claim or forfeit it.

Brazilian authorities also ordered an inspection. Reports indicate they cited work-rule violations for the crew, working-condition issues and a lack of first aid supplies. The report does not name the inspecting authority. Corazul said it would correct the first aid issue immediately, that it had appealed the detention order, and that it had moved its planned restart from November 13 to November 30. The company said passenger and crew safety remained its focus. It plans to sail from Brazil through at least April before repositioning the ship to Spain for the summer, and has left open year-round Brazilian service depending on demand.

What This Means for Owners and Managers

Buenavista went from seven years in another market, through a lay-up and a long ocean transit, to paying passengers within weeks. Rust staining, out-of-service pools, plumbing faults and the reported crew and first aid deficiencies all came to light after the ship was already being marketed.

For owners and managers bringing a secondhand vessel into a new trade, the case points to checks worth completing before a commercial debut rather than during one: hull and systems condition, crew working conditions and rest-hour compliance, and safety and medical stores.

Source: Maritime Executive

Important Note

This article is auto-curated from a third-party source for general awareness only. It is not Apeks Marine & Engineering's own reporting, and it is not legal advice, an official notice, or a substitute for the original source.

Request a Survey